Revert "[NativeAOT/ARM64] Generate frames compatible with Apple compact unwinding (#107766)" (#111405)

This reverts commit 4536b96.

Author: EgorBo

src/coreclr/jit/codegen.h

@@ -659,7 +659,6 @@ class CodeGen final : public CodeGenInterface
     virtual bool IsSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters() const;
     bool         genSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters;
     bool         genForceFuncletFrameType5;
-    bool         genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters;
 #endif // TARGET_ARM64
 
     //-------------------------------------------------------------------------

src/coreclr/jit/codegenarm64.cpp

@@ -845,19 +845,12 @@ void CodeGen::genSaveCalleeSavedRegisterGroup(regMaskTP regsMask, int spDelta, i
 
     for (int i = 0; i < regStack.Height(); ++i)
     {
-        RegPair regPair = genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters ? regStack.Top(i) : regStack.Bottom(i);
+        RegPair regPair = regStack.Bottom(i);
         if (regPair.reg2 != REG_NA)
         {
             // We can use a STP instruction.
-            if (genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters)
-            {
-                genPrologSaveRegPair(regPair.reg2, regPair.reg1, spOffset, spDelta, false, REG_IP0, nullptr);
-            }
-            else
-            {
-                genPrologSaveRegPair(regPair.reg1, regPair.reg2, spOffset, spDelta, regPair.useSaveNextPair, REG_IP0,
-                                     nullptr);
-            }
+            genPrologSaveRegPair(regPair.reg1, regPair.reg2, spOffset, spDelta, regPair.useSaveNextPair, REG_IP0,
+                                 nullptr);
 
             spOffset += 2 * slotSize;
         }
@@ -933,9 +926,8 @@ void CodeGen::genSaveCalleeSavedRegistersHelp(regMaskTP regsToSaveMask, int lowe
 
     // Save integer registers at higher addresses than floating-point registers.
 
-    regMaskTP maskSaveRegsFrame = regsToSaveMask & (RBM_FP | RBM_LR);
     regMaskTP maskSaveRegsFloat = regsToSaveMask & RBM_ALLFLOAT;
-    regMaskTP maskSaveRegsInt   = regsToSaveMask & ~maskSaveRegsFloat & ~maskSaveRegsFrame;
+    regMaskTP maskSaveRegsInt   = regsToSaveMask & ~maskSaveRegsFloat;
 
     if (maskSaveRegsFloat != RBM_NONE)
     {
@@ -947,13 +939,6 @@ void CodeGen::genSaveCalleeSavedRegistersHelp(regMaskTP regsToSaveMask, int lowe
     if (maskSaveRegsInt != RBM_NONE)
     {
         genSaveCalleeSavedRegisterGroup(maskSaveRegsInt, spDelta, lowestCalleeSavedOffset);
-        spDelta = 0;
-        lowestCalleeSavedOffset += genCountBits(maskSaveRegsInt) * FPSAVE_REGSIZE_BYTES;
-    }
-
-    if (maskSaveRegsFrame != RBM_NONE)
-    {
-        genPrologSaveRegPair(REG_FP, REG_LR, lowestCalleeSavedOffset, spDelta, false, REG_IP0, nullptr);
         // No need to update spDelta, lowestCalleeSavedOffset since they're not used after this.
     }
 }
@@ -985,20 +970,13 @@ void CodeGen::genRestoreCalleeSavedRegisterGroup(regMaskTP regsMask, int spDelta
             stackDelta = spDelta;
         }
 
-        RegPair regPair = genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters ? regStack.Bottom(i) : regStack.Top(i);
+        RegPair regPair = regStack.Top(i);
         if (regPair.reg2 != REG_NA)
         {
             spOffset -= 2 * slotSize;
 
-            if (genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters)
-            {
-                genEpilogRestoreRegPair(regPair.reg2, regPair.reg1, spOffset, stackDelta, false, REG_IP1, nullptr);
-            }
-            else
-            {
-                genEpilogRestoreRegPair(regPair.reg1, regPair.reg2, spOffset, stackDelta, regPair.useSaveNextPair,
-                                        REG_IP1, nullptr);
-            }
+            genEpilogRestoreRegPair(regPair.reg1, regPair.reg2, spOffset, stackDelta, regPair.useSaveNextPair, REG_IP1,
+                                    nullptr);
         }
         else
         {
@@ -1065,19 +1043,11 @@ void CodeGen::genRestoreCalleeSavedRegistersHelp(regMaskTP regsToRestoreMask, in
 
     // Save integer registers at higher addresses than floating-point registers.
 
-    regMaskTP maskRestoreRegsFrame = regsToRestoreMask & (RBM_FP | RBM_LR);
     regMaskTP maskRestoreRegsFloat = regsToRestoreMask & RBM_ALLFLOAT;
-    regMaskTP maskRestoreRegsInt   = regsToRestoreMask & ~maskRestoreRegsFloat & ~maskRestoreRegsFrame;
+    regMaskTP maskRestoreRegsInt   = regsToRestoreMask & ~maskRestoreRegsFloat;
 
     // Restore in the opposite order of saving.
 
-    if (maskRestoreRegsFrame != RBM_NONE)
-    {
-        int spFrameDelta = (maskRestoreRegsFloat != RBM_NONE || maskRestoreRegsInt != RBM_NONE) ? 0 : spDelta;
-        spOffset -= 2 * REGSIZE_BYTES;
-        genEpilogRestoreRegPair(REG_FP, REG_LR, spOffset, spFrameDelta, false, REG_IP1, nullptr);
-    }
-
     if (maskRestoreRegsInt != RBM_NONE)
     {
         int spIntDelta = (maskRestoreRegsFloat != RBM_NONE) ? 0 : spDelta; // should we delay the SP adjustment?

src/coreclr/jit/codegencommon.cpp

@@ -255,7 +255,6 @@ CodeGen::CodeGen(Compiler* theCompiler)
 #ifdef TARGET_ARM64
     genSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters = false;
     genForceFuncletFrameType5              = false;
-    genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters  = false;
 #endif // TARGET_ARM64
 }
 
@@ -4828,29 +4827,6 @@ void CodeGen::genFinalizeFrame()
     }
 #endif // TARGET_ARM
 
-#ifdef TARGET_ARM64
-    if (compiler->IsTargetAbi(CORINFO_NATIVEAOT_ABI) && TargetOS::IsApplePlatform)
-    {
-        JITDUMP("Setting genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters = true");
-
-        genReverseAndPairCalleeSavedRegisters = true;
-
-        // Make sure we push the registers in pairs if possible. If we only allocate a contiguous
-        // block of registers this should add at most one integer and at most one floating point
-        // register to the list. The stack has to be 16-byte aligned, so in worst case it results
-        // in allocating 16 bytes more space on stack if odd number of integer and odd number of
-        // FP registers were occupied. Same number of instructions will be generated, just the
-        // STR instructions are replaced with STP (store pair).
-        regMaskTP maskModifiedRegs = regSet.rsGetModifiedRegsMask();
-        regMaskTP maskPairRegs     = ((maskModifiedRegs & (RBM_V8 | RBM_V10 | RBM_V12 | RBM_V14)).getLow() << 1) |
-                                 ((maskModifiedRegs & (RBM_R19 | RBM_R21 | RBM_R23 | RBM_R25 | RBM_R27)).getLow() << 1);
-        if (maskPairRegs != RBM_NONE)
-        {
-            regSet.rsSetRegsModified(maskPairRegs);
-        }
-    }
-#endif
-
 #ifdef DEBUG
     if (verbose)
     {

src/coreclr/jit/compiler.hpp

@@ -2808,16 +2808,6 @@ inline
     {
         *pBaseReg = REG_SPBASE;
     }
-#elif defined(TARGET_ARM64)
-    if (FPbased && !codeGen->isFramePointerRequired() && varOffset < 0 && !opts.IsOSR() &&
-        lvaDoneFrameLayout == Compiler::FINAL_FRAME_LAYOUT && codeGen->IsSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters())
-    {
-        int spVarOffset = varOffset + codeGen->genSPtoFPdelta();
-        JITDUMP("lvaFrameAddress optimization for V%02u: [FP-%d] -> [SP+%d]\n", varNum, -varOffset, spVarOffset);
-        FPbased   = false;
-        varOffset = spVarOffset;
-    }
-    *pFPbased = FPbased;
 #else
     *pFPbased = FPbased;
 #endif

src/coreclr/jit/lclvars.cpp

@@ -5639,9 +5639,7 @@ void Compiler::lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets()
 #endif
 
     // The delta to be added to virtual offset to adjust it relative to frame pointer or SP
-    int delta            = 0;
-    int frameLocalsDelta = 0;
-    int frameBoundary    = 0;
+    int delta = 0;
 
 #ifdef TARGET_XARCH
     delta += REGSIZE_BYTES; // pushed PC (return address) for x86/x64
@@ -5666,25 +5664,7 @@ void Compiler::lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets()
         // We set FP to be after LR, FP
         delta += 2 * REGSIZE_BYTES;
     }
-#elif defined(TARGET_ARM64)
-    else
-    {
-        // FP is used.
-        delta += codeGen->genTotalFrameSize() - codeGen->genSPtoFPdelta();
-
-        // If we placed FP/LR at the bottom of the frame we need to shift all the variables
-        // on the new frame to account for it. See lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals.
-        if (!codeGen->IsSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters())
-        {
-            // We set FP to be after LR, FP
-            frameLocalsDelta = 2 * REGSIZE_BYTES;
-            frameBoundary    = opts.IsOSR() ? -info.compPatchpointInfo->TotalFrameSize() : 0;
-            if (info.compIsVarArgs)
-                frameBoundary -= MAX_REG_ARG * REGSIZE_BYTES;
-        }
-        JITDUMP("--- delta bump %d for FP frame, %d inside frame for FP/LR relocation\n", delta, frameLocalsDelta);
-    }
-#elif defined(TARGET_AMD64)
+#elif defined(TARGET_AMD64) || defined(TARGET_ARM64)
     else
     {
         // FP is used.
@@ -5752,7 +5732,7 @@ void Compiler::lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets()
 
 #if defined(TARGET_X86)
             // On x86, we set the stack offset for a promoted field
-            // to match a struct parameter in lvaAssignFrameOffsetsToPromotedStructs.
+            // to match a struct parameter in lvAssignFrameOffsetsToPromotedStructs.
             if ((!varDsc->lvIsParam || parentvarDsc->lvIsParam) && promotionType == PROMOTION_TYPE_DEPENDENT)
 #else
             if (!varDsc->lvIsParam && promotionType == PROMOTION_TYPE_DEPENDENT)
@@ -5772,23 +5752,15 @@ void Compiler::lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets()
 
         if (doAssignStkOffs)
         {
-            int localDelta = delta;
-
-            if (frameLocalsDelta != 0 && varDsc->GetStackOffset() < frameBoundary)
-            {
-                localDelta += frameLocalsDelta;
-            }
-
-            JITDUMP("-- V%02u was %d, now %d\n", lclNum, varDsc->GetStackOffset(),
-                    varDsc->GetStackOffset() + localDelta);
-            varDsc->SetStackOffset(varDsc->GetStackOffset() + localDelta);
+            JITDUMP("-- V%02u was %d, now %d\n", lclNum, varDsc->GetStackOffset(), varDsc->GetStackOffset() + delta);
+            varDsc->SetStackOffset(varDsc->GetStackOffset() + delta);
 
 #if DOUBLE_ALIGN
             if (genDoubleAlign() && !codeGen->isFramePointerUsed())
             {
                 if (varDsc->lvFramePointerBased)
                 {
-                    varDsc->SetStackOffset(varDsc->GetStackOffset() - localDelta);
+                    varDsc->SetStackOffset(varDsc->GetStackOffset() - delta);
 
                     // We need to re-adjust the offsets of the parameters so they are EBP
                     // relative rather than stack/frame pointer relative
@@ -5810,13 +5782,9 @@ void Compiler::lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets()
     assert(codeGen->regSet.tmpAllFree());
     for (TempDsc* temp = codeGen->regSet.tmpListBeg(); temp != nullptr; temp = codeGen->regSet.tmpListNxt(temp))
     {
-        temp->tdAdjustTempOffs(delta + frameLocalsDelta);
+        temp->tdAdjustTempOffs(delta);
     }
 
-    if (lvaCachedGenericContextArgOffs < frameBoundary)
-    {
-        lvaCachedGenericContextArgOffs += frameLocalsDelta;
-    }
     lvaCachedGenericContextArgOffs += delta;
 
 #if FEATURE_FIXED_OUT_ARGS
@@ -6072,6 +6040,30 @@ void Compiler::lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals()
         codeGen->setFramePointerUsed(codeGen->isFramePointerRequired());
     }
 
+#ifdef TARGET_ARM64
+    // Decide where to save FP and LR registers. We store FP/LR registers at the bottom of the frame if there is
+    // a frame pointer used (so we get positive offsets from the frame pointer to access locals), but not if we
+    // need a GS cookie AND localloc is used, since we need the GS cookie to protect the saved return value,
+    // and also the saved frame pointer. See CodeGen::genPushCalleeSavedRegisters() for more details about the
+    // frame types. Since saving FP/LR at high addresses is a relatively rare case, force using it during stress.
+    // (It should be legal to use these frame types for every frame).
+
+    if (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 0)
+    {
+        // Default configuration
+        codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters((getNeedsGSSecurityCookie() && compLocallocUsed) ||
+                                                        opts.compDbgEnC || compStressCompile(STRESS_GENERIC_VARN, 20));
+    }
+    else if (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 1)
+    {
+        codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters(false); // Disable using new frames
+    }
+    else if ((opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 2) || (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 3))
+    {
+        codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters(true); // Force using new frames
+    }
+#endif // TARGET_ARM64
+
 #ifdef TARGET_XARCH
     // On x86/amd64, the return address has already been pushed by the call instruction in the caller.
     stkOffs -= TARGET_POINTER_SIZE; // return address;
@@ -6120,13 +6112,9 @@ void Compiler::lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals()
 #endif // !TARGET_ARM
 
 #ifdef TARGET_ARM64
-    // If the frame pointer is used, then we'll save FP/LR either at the bottom of the stack
-    // or at the top of the stack depending on frame type. We make the decision after assigning
-    // the variables on the frame and then fix up the offsets in lvaFixVirtualFrameOffsets.
-    // For now, we proceed as if FP/LR were saved with the callee registers. If we later
-    // decide to move the FP/LR to the bottom of the frame it shifts all the assigned
-    // variables and temporaries by 16 bytes. The largest alignment we currently make is 16
-    // bytes for SIMD.
+    // If the frame pointer is used, then we'll save FP/LR at the bottom of the stack.
+    // Otherwise, we won't store FP, and we'll store LR at the top, with the other callee-save
+    // registers (if any).
 
     int initialStkOffs = 0;
     if (info.compIsVarArgs)
@@ -6137,7 +6125,17 @@ void Compiler::lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals()
         stkOffs -= initialStkOffs;
     }
 
-    stkOffs -= compCalleeRegsPushed * REGSIZE_BYTES;
+    if (codeGen->IsSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters() || !isFramePointerUsed()) // Note that currently we always have
+                                                                                   // a frame pointer
+    {
+        stkOffs -= compCalleeRegsPushed * REGSIZE_BYTES;
+    }
+    else
+    {
+        // Subtract off FP and LR.
+        assert(compCalleeRegsPushed >= 2);
+        stkOffs -= (compCalleeRegsPushed - 2) * REGSIZE_BYTES;
+    }
 
 #elif defined(TARGET_LOONGARCH64) || defined(TARGET_RISCV64)
 
@@ -6807,6 +6805,15 @@ void Compiler::lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals()
     }
 #endif // TARGET_AMD64
 
+#ifdef TARGET_ARM64
+    if (!codeGen->IsSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters() && isFramePointerUsed()) // Note that currently we always have
+                                                                                   // a frame pointer
+    {
+        // Create space for saving FP and LR.
+        stkOffs -= 2 * REGSIZE_BYTES;
+    }
+#endif // TARGET_ARM64
+
 #if FEATURE_FIXED_OUT_ARGS
     if (lvaOutgoingArgSpaceSize > 0)
     {
@@ -6844,44 +6851,6 @@ void Compiler::lvaAssignVirtualFrameOffsetsToLocals()
 
     noway_assert(compLclFrameSize + originalFrameSize ==
                  (unsigned)-(stkOffs + (pushedCount * (int)TARGET_POINTER_SIZE)));
-
-#ifdef TARGET_ARM64
-    // Decide where to save FP and LR registers. We store FP/LR registers at the bottom of the frame if there is
-    // a frame pointer used (so we get positive offsets from the frame pointer to access locals), but not if we
-    // need a GS cookie AND localloc is used, since we need the GS cookie to protect the saved return value,
-    // and also the saved frame pointer. See CodeGen::genPushCalleeSavedRegisters() for more details about the
-    // frame types. Since saving FP/LR at high addresses is a relatively rare case, force using it during stress.
-    // (It should be legal to use these frame types for every frame).
-    //
-    // For Apple NativeAOT ABI we try to save the FP/LR registers on top to get canonical frame layout that can
-    // be represented with compact unwinding information. In order to maintain code quality we only do it when
-    // we can use SP-based addressing (!isFramePointerRequired) through lvaFrameAddress optimization, or if the
-    // whole frame is small enough that the negative FP-based addressing can address the whole frame.
-
-    if (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 0)
-    {
-        if (IsTargetAbi(CORINFO_NATIVEAOT_ABI) && TargetOS::IsApplePlatform &&
-            (!codeGen->isFramePointerRequired() || codeGen->genTotalFrameSize() < 0x100))
-        {
-            codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters(true);
-        }
-        else
-        {
-            // Default configuration
-            codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters((getNeedsGSSecurityCookie() && compLocallocUsed) ||
-                                                            opts.compDbgEnC ||
-                                                            compStressCompile(Compiler::STRESS_GENERIC_VARN, 20));
-        }
-    }
-    else if (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 1)
-    {
-        codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters(false); // Disable using new frames
-    }
-    else if ((opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 2) || (opts.compJitSaveFpLrWithCalleeSavedRegisters == 3))
-    {
-        codeGen->SetSaveFpLrWithAllCalleeSavedRegisters(true); // Force using new frames
-    }
-#endif // TARGET_ARM64
 }
 
 //------------------------------------------------------------------------

src/coreclr/tools/aot/ILCompiler.Compiler/Compiler/ObjectWriter/MachNative.cs

@@ -120,18 +120,5 @@ internal static class MachNative
         public const uint PLATFORM_TVOSSIMULATOR = 8;
         public const uint PLATFORM_WATCHOSSIMULATOR = 9;
         public const uint PLATFORM_DRIVERKIT = 10;
-
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_MODE_FRAMELESS = 0x02000000;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_MODE_DWARF = 0x03000000;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_MODE_FRAME = 0x04000000;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_X19_X20_PAIR = 0x00000001;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_X21_X22_PAIR = 0x00000002;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_X23_X24_PAIR = 0x00000004;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_X25_X26_PAIR = 0x00000008;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_X27_X28_PAIR = 0x00000010;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_D8_D9_PAIR = 0x00000100;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_D10_D11_PAIR = 0x00000200;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_D12_D13_PAIR = 0x00000400;
-        public const uint UNWIND_ARM64_FRAME_D14_D15_PAIR = 0x00000800;
     }
 }